"As the only tall masted ship in the pirate range I thought that it would be a good purchase. I was slightly dissapointed. As a set on its own is seems to have limits with playability when compared with other Lego sets of a similar price range. The vessel is nonetheless packed with features such as the pirate captains cabin, detailed gundeck, plank (to be 'walked') and bilge, however, the details lack functionality and seem to be more for decoration than activity such as the crossed swords on the stern.
There are some interesting features, the single cannon on the wheel deck makes aligning the ship for attack a thing of the past however I feel myself being drawn to what I believe is the main disadvantage of this themed range as it stands, the lack of another similar vessel with which battle can be drawn on the open ocean (or carpet depending where your imagination takes you)
Concentrating on the set there are lots of minifigures as well as a huge shark (was expecting the old casting of shark however you can get a minifigure in the mouth of this beast!), mouse (or possibly rat) and monkey with a cheeky banana. Set includes two additional cannon which sit on the main gun deck but with the rigging moving them around inside the hull can be awkward, as can firing them. Found that there is a lack of 'cannonballs' which for three cannon, I would have expected more than seven shot! Also found that loading the cannon can be rather awkward as the shot does not want to naturally slide down into the barrel and missfires can be a common occurance, much to the frustration in the heat of a 'battle'.
Construction is simple with two books and four numbered bags. The hull retains the same maindeck baseplates as the original pirate ships (dark-shark and soldiers cutter) however the bow and stern are now made up of five main 'bricks' in total making future adaptation easier and less limiting. The captains cabin is modular and removable to access the bilge.
I would have expected more features from the set, which if you do buy it, and I'm certainly not trying to stop you, you could add yourselves such as beds for the pirates in the bilge, barrels for 'powder', racks for the weapons, a locker in the bow (as there seems to be quite a lot of empty room here) and a couple of bricks that keep the deck cannon from rolling back when you try to fire them (otherwise an awkward two handed operation where there is only room for one!) All of these can be obtained through the pick-a brick part of the website and will make the set much better.
Overall, I would have expected more from the feature set in the theme but sadly disappointed by the emphasis on detail as opposed to playability. If you have other sets such as the soldiers fort then I can imagine (as I don't have it at time of review) that playability will be much better but as a set on it's own it is sadly limited. 6/10"